Sex and Freedom in Early Book Two
Some things I noticed in the beginning of Book Two were the bits on sex that made me a slightly uncomfortable while reading. For starters, Winston admitting to Julia his horrific desires/fantasies regarding her, only to be met with her laughing delightedly felt like a weird and gross decision on Orwell's part. Generally reading about what Winston says he imagined is uncomfortable to me, but the way he says it like it's no big deal, as well as her reaction, make my experience less even less enjoyable. After this, I didn't particularly like Winston describing Julia's sexual habits as foul and impure, but I recognize that this is attributed more to the values ingrained in the dystopian society in which they live rather than Orwell's personal biases.
I also feel like for a society with such stern control on human freedoms, Winston and Julia being able to sustain their relationship and activities for so long seems unrealistic. At the beginning of the book, Winston was basically saying that he accepted death after starting his diary, and one would think that in a society where thought police exist, he would not still be around so long after starting it. Not only has he avoided punishment for that offense, but he is currently engaging in a loving affair with another member of the party, something that seems incredibly against this society's values. Given that he talks about not being able to do his job on account of the feelings Julia's note evoked in him, it feels preposterous that he has not yet been found out. Not to mention Julia has been doing this sort of thing since way before she even gave him the note.
Anyway, I'd love to hear your thoughts on these things, or anything else in the reading that you might have found interesting.
I agree, the sex in this book is uncomfortable to read about. There's a definite misogyny from Winston which might also be from Orwell. At the same time, part of the Party's control of humanity -- part of any tyrannical society's control -- is on sexuality, so the discomfort is probably a reflection of this. (As for why they've been able to sustain their relationship ... keep reading.)
ReplyDeleteI completely agree. I really hate Winston and the complete brush off and acceptance of what he wanted to do to Julia was disgusting. Also his line about not being able to call her beautiful really confused me because he has been obsessed with her since the moment he saw her and it just shows a very strange part of his character. It highlighted this point that he's seemingly only using her for sex. I also think it's very unrealistic that they haven't been caught yet especially since they started using the room over Mr. Charrington's shop.
ReplyDeleteI actually did a blog post on Winston's misogyny from part one, and I totally agree with you! His idea that women exist for him to have sex with, while simultaneously hating on women for having sex- well that's just sexism 101.
ReplyDeleteI thought he loved Julia for being promiscuous. To be fair, though, that is only because it represented rebelliousness against the Party
Delete